Darkness Becomes Her by Kelly Keaton
* Feb 22, 2011 *
- paranormal, YA -
reviewed by Tara SG
received for review via Book It Forward Tours

Book Order (Gods & Monsters)
- Darkness Becomes Her (Feb 22, 2011) *
Links
Author’s Website : www.kellykeaton.net
Author’s Twitter : @kellykeaton
Amazon : pre-order hardcover / pre-order eBook
Add To Your GoodReads TBR List (41 ratings : 4.01 avg)
In Six Words
muddled mixed mythologies and missing romance
Why did I read this? And am I glad I did?
I came across this via the tour site and it sounded right up my alley. I did not enjoy this one. Although it seems from my brief glance on GoodReads that people either loved or hated it. While I have no issue with mixed Greeky mythology and paranormal creatures (hence my love of DH), it did not work well in this book. Too much was left unexplained and there was no connection between the two mythologies which I found confusing. I was also disappointed in the romance. I honestly felt like there were chapters missing. I won’t be finishing out this series.
Brief Summary
Ari can’t help feeling lost and alone. With teal eyes and freakish silver hair that can’t be changed or destroyed, Ari has always stood out. And after growing up in foster care, she longs for some understanding of where she came from and who she is.
Her search for answers uncovers just one message from her long dead mother: Run. Ari can sense that someone, or something, is getting closer than they should. But it’s impossible to protect herself when she doesn’t know what she’s running from or why she is being pursued.
She knows only one thing: she must return to her birthplace of New 2, the lush rebuilt city of New Orleans. Upon arriving, she discovers that New 2 is very…different. Here, Ari is seemingly normal. But every creature she encounters, no matter how deadly or horrifying, is afraid of her.
Ari won’t stop until she knows why. But some truths are too haunting, too terrifying, to ever be revealed.
- via GoodReads.com
Plot/Pacing/Writing Style
There was a lot of promise in the storyline that got lost. The idea of NOLA being hit by insane hurricanes and the US selling it due to being unable to rebuild was original and intriguing. It wasn’t a surprise to me that paranormal creatures would be living there. The fact that it wasn’t a surprise to Ari whatsoever was unbelievable.
The curse could have been a really great plot on its own if there weren’t so many other paranormal mythologies in the mix. I was extremely pleased to find out what she was and to be honest I’m a little curious to find out how she deals with it in the future… just not enough to keep reading the books.
I liked the author’s descriptions and the feel of New 2 was great. But there was WAY too much cussing. Don’t get me wrong I love cuss words in older YA books. I don’t even mind the f-word being used. As long as it seems appropriate for the characters and the situation. Here it was overdone to the point where the characters sounded unintelligent instead of tough.
Characters
Ari wasn’t a terrible lead (aside from the cussing). Her reaction to New 2 – or lack there of – bothered me, but otherwise her personality seemed to fit with someone having grown-up the way she did.
The romance really killed the story for me. The guy went from being a super hot stranger to her boyfriend in a matter of pages. I was confused during the first kiss because I couldn’t understand how she could feel so strongly about someone she just met. It wasn’t even played off as a “love at first sight” or some magical bond (which I can sometimes understand).
Recommendations
If you like older, darker paranormal YA, I would suggest picking this up from a friend or the library only because so many other people seemed to have enjoyed it a lot more than I did. If however, your tastes seem to be very similar to mine (you ladies know who I’m talking to) then don’t bother with this one.
Other posts with a 1 star rating



Great review of a novel you didn’t enjoy. Those are really hard to do. I loved the cover of this one and on that alone was going to try it. But I read the synopsis of it and thought I’d wait until others read it. Glad I read your review. There are other great books to read so I won’t waste my time!
Heather
@ Heather Rosdol : Thank you! I hate writing reviews for a book I didn’t like. I liked the cover and the synopsis, but unfortunately couldn’t get behind the romance or mythology.
Darn. Really? I was hoping you’d enjoy this one. Lol. Usually reading reviews from people who didn’t enjoy the book doesn’t do a whole lot to stop me from reading it anyway, but you and I have scarily similar tastes. I do have access to an e-galley though, so maybe I’ll give it a shot since I don’t have to pay out of pocket. Thanks for your honesty!
@ Natalie : Urgh I know. Well I hate to say “don’t try it” if you have a free copy. Maybe start it and if you don’t like the beginning you can feel better about it being a DNF?
The ‘suddenly this stranger is the love of my life’ thing almost always drives me up the wall. I like a little initial tension and pursuing in relationships.
Sorry this one didn’t work out for you.
@ Alita : Very seldom does it work for me. There has to be a GREAT connection between the characters that this was definitely missing.
hey, love ur cool blog and its awesome name! new follower just stopping by, feel free to stop by my blog at http://www.sabaawesome.blogspot.com, thx!
Awww too bad on this one as I so love Greek mythology when it’s combined with other paranormal elements! I don’t like when the romance is instantaneous for no apparent reason though, I just can’t get on board when that’s how it plays out. Thanks for this honest review Tara, I think I’ll pass on this one!
@ Jenny : I know! I was really hoping to like this one. Even without the instant romance, the mythology didn’t blend well enough for me to give the next in the series a chance
I’ve only ever seen glowing reviews for this one. I’m surprised here. I don’t think expletives make someone tough, in fact character who can speak threateningly without cursing are more scary.
I will definitely pass. Thanks for the inside look Tara.
@ Missie : This seems like a love it or hate it book. I don’t like to say “don’t bother” when so many people loved it, I just can’t personally recommend it :/
Pingback: A Touch Mortal {early ARC review} * * * * « 25 Hour Books
Pingback: Darkness Becomes Her by Kelly Keaton – Advance Review